All Time Stories
← Wanted

Whose Side

October 7, 2026 · Episode 5

Never miss the next episodeGet an alert the moment it drops in the free All Time Stories app.Get the app

Episode recap

The moonlight over the crumbling mission church cast long, jagged shadows as Cass Delgado felt the cold steel of a revolver barrel against the nape of her neck. Inside the sanctuary, Sheriff Hollis and the Ghost’s gang were shoulder-deep in stolen gold, confirming the ultimate betrayal of the law Cass once served. Now, caught between the corrupt sheriff inside and a gun-wielding companion behind her, Cass realized her ten-year quest had led her into a lethal trap.

What happened The silence of the Texas night felt heavy as Cass stood frozen, the metal of the gun a stinging reminder of her misplaced trust in Eli. A bitter realization washed over her as she looked at the man who had claimed to be her ally: He was the sheriff's man all along. I should have shot him in the desert. She expected the hammer to click or a shout to alert the outlaws inside, but instead, the pressure of the barrel vanished. Eli did not pull the trigger. But he lowered the gun and pulled me into the dark, dragging her behind a weathered stone buttress just as a torchlight flickered near the church’s open door. In the stifling shadows, Eli’s voice was a frantic, low rasp that didn't sound like the voice of a traitor. Every trail he gave the sheriff was false, he whispered, explaining that his role in Hollis’s inner circle was a calculated deception. For a decade, Eli had played a dangerous double game, acting as the sheriff's scout while secretly sabotaging the hunt for the Ghost from the inside to keep the two forces from ever truly meeting.

The twist As the sound of Hollis counting gold coins echoed through the stone walls, the true nature of Eli’s mission came to light. He had not been working for the sheriff to line his own pockets, nor was he truly helping the Ghost evade justice for the sake of the gang. He had been protecting someone for ten years, but the target of his protection was not who Cass expected. Eli confessed that his primary goal was never to shield the outlaw from the law. He had been shielding Cass herself. He had spent years planting decoys and leading the sheriff on wild goose chases to ensure that Cass’s path would never actually cross with the man she was hunting. Eli looked at her with a mix of pity and fear, revealing the burden he had carried. He was protecting not the Ghost from me. Me, from finding out who the Ghost is.

What to watch for next Now that Eli has revealed his true colors, can Cass actually trust him to lead her to the truth, or is this another layer of the sheriff's manipulation? If the Ghost’s identity is so terrible that it required ten years of lies to hide, how will Cass react when she finally comes face-to-face with her past? With Sheriff Hollis and the gang just a few feet away, will the unlikely duo be able to slip away from the mission before they are discovered?